DoorDash vs Postmates for Customers: Which is Better?

DoorDash-vs-Postmates-for-Customers-featured

Here, we’ve compared DoorDash vs Postmates to highlight areas in which one may have an advantage, and show whether you may prefer to try one over the other.

After all, in today’s fast-paced society, convenience is king.

On-demand services are all the rage with this trend, and food delivery services are soaring in popularity within this area.

Especially during the COVID-19 pandemic and subsequent economical shutdowns, food delivery apps have become a go-to for many people throughout the world and especially in the United States.

These two of the most popular food delivery apps offer delivery from local restaurants throughout the country.

While they have much in common, they do differ in many respects.

Take a peek to see which one may work best for you.

Postmates or DoorDash User Comparison

When comparing Postmates vs DoorDash, there are many factors to consider.

Between all of the many factors to look at, we believe the following are most important from a customer’s perspective:

  • Available areas
  • Variety of restaurant options
  • Promotional partnerships
  • User-friendliness
  • Pricing & fees
  • Opportunities for existing users
  • Customer service & support

While both of these food delivery services are fantastic in their own right, there may be a category or two that may be more important to your particular experience.

Read on to compare these factors for a comprehensive DoorDash and Postmates food delivery comparison.

Available Areas

Postmates vs DoorDash Available Areas

In the Postmates vs DoorDash comparison, the first thing to look at would be whether they’re even both available in your area.

If you live in a large city, you most certainly have access to both.

Beyond that, DoorDash has a slight advantage.

Postmates has seen exponential growth over the past few years. As of April 2019, they are available in over 3,500 U.S. cities in all 50 states and Washington, D.C. They cite the ability to cover about 80% of U.S. households with their current availability and plans to continue expansion.

DoorDash has also shown incredible growth over the past few years, going from serving about 50 U.S. cities to offering delivery in over 4,000 cities within the U.S. and Canada as of May 2019. They also plan to continue expanding.

Popular U.S. cities for both apps include:

  • NYC
  • Los Angeles
  • San Antonio
  • Atlanta
  • Orange County
  • Chicago
  • San Diego
  • Denver
  • Inland Empire
  • Washington, DC
  • Santa Cruz
  • Reno
  • Charlotte
  • Seattle
  • Sacramento
  • Houston

There are many, many more popular cities, of course, both these are just some that enjoy these delivery service options the most.

Variety of Restaurant Options

Is DoorDash or Postmates better when it comes to variety?

Both food delivery apps offer a wide variety of restaurant options.

How many & who wins?

Postmates takes the win in this category.

The San Fransisco-based app offers over 600,000 options.

DoorDash offers about 340,000, which is quite a lot and very impressive, but not quite as many as their competitor.

If variety is something that’s important to you, then Postmates is going to be your best bet.

One thing also to consider is the fact that you can also get your groceries with Postmates.

Pretty nifty, huh?

They offer delivery from grocery stores as well as the option to request delivery from any restaurant or grocery store in your area, even if it isn’t part of their platform.

Promotional Partnerships

Postmates vs DoorDash Promotional Partners

Do you like getting deals and perks with your food deliveries?

No matter which food delivery app you choose, you may want to pay attention to this.

Some restaurant partners have exclusive deals with one of the delivery companies and will offer special promotions as a result.

So which app has more?

Both apps offer a good amount of exclusive incentives, but the Postmates service typically has a bigger variety.

They have delivery partnerships with restaurants such as:

  • The Coffee Bean & Tea Leaf
  • Burger King
  • Jamba
  • Denny’s
  • Carl’s Jr.
  • Subway
  • Tacos El Unico
  • Tender Greens

DoorDash offers promotion opportunities for its consumers with the following partners:

  • The Cheesecake Factory
  • Chipotle
  • Cracker Barrel
  • Wendy’s
  • Wyndham Hotels

There are many more, of course, and even more coming as these services surge in popularity.

User-friendliness

Especially when it comes to ordering food, people want to get through the process as quickly and simply as possible.

On-demand delivery apps such as these take that into account when creating their ordering system and user interface.

So what’s better, DoorDash or Postmates?

This one is pretty even, actually.

Thankfully, both apps are very user-friendly, with quick ordering processes.

In terms of pros and cons within this category, they both have the same attributes.

On the pros side of things, they both allow you to create an order before requiring any payment information. Having to input payment information first can be quite frustrating, so this is a plus for both apps.

Also, both offer real-time tracking of your order, which is a big factor for some customers to reinforce their peace of mind while waiting for their orders.

As far as cons, the only one that sticks out is actually true for both options.

You are required to create an account before browsing through available options in your area, which can result in frustration on the part of the customer, especially if you’re already hungry!

That being said, we believe in this case that the pros outweigh the cons, and both the DoorDash app and the Postmates app are set up to be quite user-friendly and focused on pleasant customer experiences throughout the process.

Pricing & Fees

DoorDash vs Postmates Prices & Fees

And now for the thing that most people want to know: is Postmates or DoorDash cheaper?

Both meal delivery services have a similar structure for prices and fees, so the comparison is pretty straightforward.

Whether you’re using Postmates or DoorDash, you’re going to see a combination of the following items:

  • Actual food cost (the cost of the food you’re ordering)
  • Service fee (company fee to cover resources & costs)
  • Sales taxes (varies by location)
  • The delivery fee (cost of delivery via courier)
  • Gratuity (tips are encouraged but not required)

So, let’s compare.

For DoorDash, the situation would look something like this:

  • Restaurant partners select the prices of their meals. You may notice differences between the usual menu price, as they typically mark them up higher to recoup some of the cost of their merchant fees. DoorDash sets the prices for any non-partner restaurants in their app. These prices may be marked up as well.
  • The service fee is typically around 10-11%, although it too may vary by merchant and by city.
  • Sales tax will be charged depending on your local tax rate.
  • The delivery fee varies by city and by the restaurant, typically ranging from $1.99 to $5.99 (you can place an order without a delivery fee by choosing pickup instead).
  • Delivery fees are higher during surge pricing times (peak hours, usually during lunch and dinner).
  • Tipping is optional but encouraged. You may tip through the app or in cash.
  • DoorDash does charge a small order fee of $2 if the total falls below its minimum amount.

Now looking at Postmates, their payment criteria are as follows:

  • Postmates selects their prices are selected just like DoorDash, with partnered merchants choosing their own pricing, and Postmates setting non-partnered restaurants’ costs themselves.
  • The service fee is also a percentage, which varies. It’s typically around 15%.
  • Sales tax is added according to your local tax rate.
  • The delivery fee varies by merchant. The fee for partnered merchants is typically between $0.99-3.99, and the fee for non-partnered merchants usually runs between $5.99-9.99. These may vary by area as well. Merchants will quite often offer free delivery, especially during non-peak hours.
  • Delivery fees are higher during peak hours as well, which is called ‘Blitz pricing.’
  • Tipping is also encouraged, but not required. The app offers the ability to tip, although you may use cash as well.
  • Postmates also charges a small order fee of $1.99; the minimum is typically $12 although it can vary by city.

After looking at this direct comparison, they stack up pretty neck-to-neck.

It really depends on your local city, which restaurant you order from, and what time of the day you order.

Using these points, you should be able to use these factors to your advantage to save on your deliveries!

Opportunities for Existing Users

DoorDash DashPass for Existing Users

While neither service specifically offers promo codes for existing users (this is typical for most on-demand services), both do offer membership programs with built-in savings for regular purchases.

Postmates offers a program called Postmates Unlimited.

As a Postmates customer enrolled in this program, you would enjoy the following benefits:

  • Free delivery for all orders over $10 (minimum sometimes varies by location)
  • No blitz pricing during peak hours
  • Special offers for members
  • Exclusive giveaway & event access

This program costs either $9.99 monthly or $99.99 yearly and is estimated to save users an average of $185 yearly with just two orders per month.

DoorDash offers a program called DashPass.

DashPass features include:

  • Free delivery on orders from specific DoorDash restaurant partners (order minimum is $12)
  • Reduced service fees on orders over $12
  • Special deals for Chase cardholders

DashPass also costs $9.99 monthly and claims to save about $4-5 per order, so even just ordering twice per month makes up for the cost in savings.

With the same monthly cost (and even lower yearly cost), a wider variety of benefits, and a lower order minimum, Postmates pulls ahead of DoorDash in this comparison category.

Customer Service & Support

How about when you have an issue with your food order and need help?

Is Postmates better than DoorDash with customer service, or vice versa?

DoorDash gets the win in this category with many more ways to get in touch.

They used to only have email support, but they’ve upped their game in response to some competitors offering better solutions as well as customers requesting the ability to call via phone or use chat support.

Ask, and you shall receive.

They now offer the following support platforms:

  • Chat support through their app or website
  • Phone support (855-973-1040)
  • Email ([email protected])
  • Contact form via website or app

Postmates, on the other hand, only offers a contact form for customer service (be sure to use the correct one; they have one for consumers, one for couriers, and one for merchants).

Alternatively, you could seek help via social media as they are highly responsive on platforms such as Twitter (@Postmates_Help) and Facebook.

Both services also have extensive FAQ and help sections for customers to clear up any issues on their own if desired.

DoorDash or Postmates: Overall Conclusion

DoorDash vs Postmates

So, when cravings hit, who are you going to order with?

Well, it depends.

If you’re getting food delivery often, and you’re looking at a membership program to save as a regular user, then you may want to look at Postmates.

The reason?

The difference in rates is pretty nonexistent for Unlimited members, but they have a larger variety and they feature more promotions to choose from.

If you’re just looking to place sporadic orders here and there, you may have more of an advantage with DoorDash.

Their one-off costs are going to be slightly less due to their lower service and delivery fees.

Our advice would be to try them both and see which one you prefer!

There are fantastic benefits to each of these businesses, and many of the categories listed here are a matter of personal preference.

We’d suggest trying each for yourself to see which one works best for you.

DoorDash and Postmates FAQs

What’s the deal with the DoorDash vs. Postmates Reddit thread?

If you’re on the hunt for a promo code, be wary of the promotions listed on Reddit for both of these services. They’re just referral codes posted by existing users in an attempt to receive some account credit. These codes will only work for new users to the platform, and even then it’s hit and miss. You’d be better off using an official promo code that has been verified to work.

Does either DoorDash or Postmates take PayPal?

No, unfortunately, neither app accepts PayPal for payments at this time.

Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on reddit

How useful was this article?

Click on a star to rate it!

Average rating 5 / 5. Vote count: 1

No votes so far! Be the first to rate this article.

We are sorry that this article was not useful for you!

Let us improve this post!

Tell us how we can improve this post?